This old Mayfair pub has seen its fair share of action with a history dating back to the 1800s. Now refurbed and styled as a gastropub, The Audley is more upmarket than your typical boozer, mirroring Mayfair chicness whilst still giving nods to its Victorian roots. There’s a real buzz in the air, with hordes of after-work drinkers gathered around the dining room, but little wall nooks give booth-like privacy, allowing you the option to escape the general hubbub as you eat.
The menu specialises in no-nonsense pub grub, the kind of food you might cosy up to in your local, with a tankard of cutlery on the side. We start our evening with a scotch egg: slightly misshapen with a hard, golden shell that when broken gives a hefty crunch. The yolk still oozes, a runny centre to the thick outer layer, that’s expertly cooked and nicely seasoned.
The mains, whilst tasty, fall flat after what had been an exceptional starter. The steak and ale pie is a proper all-pastry pie, but the innards are a bit dry, relying too much on the additional gravy and lacking any greenery on the side. Battered fish is soft and flaky on the inside, with a light, crisp coating, but the chips could have benefitted from a few more minutes in the fryer. They’re relatively small issues but The Audley is at the top-end of gastropub prices.
Dinner ends on a high. Tart apples come completely enclosed in a light, almost flaky, pastry, sprinkled with icing sugar and paired with a runny homemade vanilla custard – the proper stuff, in our opinion. It perfectly hits the sweet spot, leaving us largely positive about The Audley. Is it the perfect gastropub? No, but portions here are large, filling, and overall good value for money, and you won’t find many more beautiful pubs in London.